Daveen and I recently enjoyed brunch with one of our daughters and her husband. For whatever reason he and I started talking about raising children.
To my delight, we agreed on two very important aspects of parenting.
I said that my father did a pretty good job, with two exceptions.
The first was spanking. Dad spanked my brother and me as a punishment. (Fortunately, I was never on his “go to bed without dinner list.” That was reserved for my younger brother, who was, shall we say, less strategic than I was.). While researchers have now made the case against using any kind of physical discipline against kids, some still use it.
Second was Dad’s insistence that I “finish everything on my plate,” even if I didn’t put it there. I was told repeatedly about all the starving children in China. If I had thought of it at the time, I would have asked him exactly how the remnant of my dinner would be transported to China, but a snarky comment like that would probably have resulted in being sent to bed without my own dinner the following night.
When I was ten years old I made two promises to myself.
First, that I would never hit another person, and I haven’t.
I also vowed that I would never require my children to finish everything on their plate. I’m not blaming my dad, because I’m sure he didn’t know better, but forcing kids to eat teaches them to ignore their own hunger cues and can result in overeating. That might have been one reason I weighed more than two hundred pounds when I graduated high school. (My weight was 207, as I recall, eventually ballooning to 267 pounds.)
Raising children is a privilege, but one that we are seldom trained for. Most of us simply do to our children what our parents did to us.
I’m suggesting that we all rethink our habits, and retain those that are both useful and kind, especially with our greatest treasure — our children.
Spare the rod?
Absolutely.
Alan